Dutch box 3 reform should wait until 2030, Council of State says
The Council of State calls the amendment unworkable for 2028. For owner-directors, a lower box 2 top rate and a stricter limit on borrowing from their own company are also in doubt.

The Dutch box 3 reform, which taxes actual returns on savings and investments, should only take effect in 2030 and in a single step, the Council of State (Raad van State) advises. The cabinet wanted to start in 2028; until a new system is in place, the current flat-rate levy with its counter-evidence scheme would continue.
The Council’s advisory division recommends that the government withdraw the Actual Return Box 3 Bill and not submit the amendment (novelle) to the House of Representatives, according to the advice published on 2 November. The original bill taxed the annual increase in value (accrual) from 1 January 2028, with exceptions for real estate and start-up companies, which would only be taxed on sale (capital gains).
The amendment also moves financial instruments to the capital gains tax from 2028. Savings, receivables, directly held crypto and some insurance products would remain under the accrual tax for now, Fiscaal Vanmorgen reports. That would create a hybrid system until 2030. The Council says this distinction is hard to justify and vulnerable to legal challenges.
For owner-directors with a large current account, the borrowing limit is the figure to watch.
Box 3 reform unworkable for 2028
The implementation test by the Belastingdienst (the Dutch tax authority), which the Council received on 22 October, is negative on all five parts examined. The tax authority considers the amendment technically possible but not workable for tax year 2028. Banks cannot supply all the data needed to determine gains on investments, so taxpayers would have to calculate their own disposal gains. The temporary system would require 252 FTE and around €31 million in extra implementation costs.
If the cabinet sticks with the amendment, the Council advises introducing the box 3 reform with a capital gains tax for all assets only in 2030. Under both options, the current flat-rate system stays in place in 2028 and 2029.
What the advice means for owner-directors
The financing directly affects business owners with a private limited company (bv). The limit on excessive borrowing from your own company would fall from €500,000 to €100,000 from 2027, in five annual steps of €80,000; in return, the top box 2 rate would temporarily drop to 29.2%. The cabinet expects owner-directors (dga’s) to take money out of their companies as a result, but the Council doubts this and notes that it brings tax revenue forward. Read also why business stakes lead the wealth of Dutch millionaires.
The reduction of the tax-free allowance to €30,846 and a deemed return of 7.87% on other assets in 2027 also lack sufficient political support, according to the Council. The cabinet has not yet responded to the advice. The House holds an extra procedural meeting on 3 November about how to handle the amendment.


